|
Quotes & Info
|
| SAIA > SEC Filings for SAIA > Form 10-K on 17-Feb-2006 | All Recent SEC Filings |
17-Feb-2006
Annual Report
Results of Operations
SCS Transportation, Inc. and Subsidiaries
Selected Results of Operations and Operating Statistics
For the years ended December 31, 2005, 2004 and 2003
(in thousands, except ratios and revenue per hundredweight)
Percent Variance
2005 2004 2003 '05 v. '04 '04 v. '03
Operating Revenue $ 1,098,031 $ 982,270 $ 827,359 11.8 % 18.7 %
Operating Expenses:
Salaries, wages and employees'
benefits 594,644 549,511 465,714 8.2 18.0
Purchased transportation 99,134 92,099 81,551 7.6 12.9
Depreciation and amortization 48,204 47,968 44,039 0.5 8.9
Other operating expenses 301,407 251,858 203,173 19.7 24.0
Operating Income 54,642 40,834 32,882 33.8 24.2
Nonoperating Expenses 9,254 9,423 8,970 (1.8 ) 5.1
Operating Ratio 95.0 % 95.8 % 96.0 % (0.8 ) (0.2 )
Working Capital 37,658 54,066 65,638 (30.3 ) (17.6 )
Cash Flow from Operations 83,353 54,894 58,270 51.8 (5.8 )
Cash Used in Investing
Activities 53,701 79,992 49,830 (32.9 ) 60.5
Operating Statistics:
LTL Tonnage
Saia 3,144 2,909 2,422 8.1 20.1
Jevic 1,007 1,066 1,053 (5.2 ) 0.9
Total Tonnage
Saia 3,802 3,526 2,977 7.8 18.4
Jevic 2,209 2,283 2,209 (2.9 ) 3.0
LTL Shipments
Saia 5,637 5,290 4,504 6.6 17.5
Jevic 847 886 877 (4.1 ) 0.7
Total Shipments
Saia 5,727 5,372 4,575 6.6 17.4
Jevic 986 1,030 1,012 (3.8 ) 1.3
LTL Revenue Per Hundredweight
Saia 11.10 10.28 9.91 8.0 3.7
Jevic 10.89 10.23 9.55 6.4 7.1
Saia (excluding fuel surcharge) 9.94 9.64 9.54 3.1 1.1
Jevic (excluding fuel surcharge) 9.72 9.59 9.19 1.4 4.4
Total Revenue Per Hundredweight
Saia 9.92 9.16 8.75 8.3 4.7
Jevic 7.51 7.11 6.70 5.6 6.2
Saia (excluding fuel surcharge) 8.95 8.63 8.44 3.7 2.3
Jevic (excluding fuel surcharge) 6.70 6.67 6.44 0.5 3.5
|
Year ended December 31, 2005 vs. year ended December 31, 2004
Revenue and volume
Consolidated revenue increased 11.8 percent to $1,098 million as a result of
improved pricing at both operating subsidiaries and increased volumes as both
shipments and LTL tonnage were up significantly at Saia over the prior year.
Volume gains were attributable to improved market share gains into and out of
Saia's newer Midwest markets, favorable economic conditions across Saia's
network, industry consolidation and company specific initiatives. Fuel surcharge
revenue, which was 10 percent of total revenue in 2005, was up significantly
from 2004 when fuel surcharge revenue was 5.9 percent of total revenue. The fuel
surcharge program is intended to reduce the
Company's exposure to rising diesel prices and other costs affected by increased
fuel prices, such as purchased transportation. While fuel costs increased
significantly during 2005, higher fuel surcharge revenues have more than offset
higher diesel fuel costs. However, in recent years, given the significance of
fuel surcharges, the negotiation of customer price increases have become
commingled with fuel surcharges. As such it now represents more than a pass
through of increased fuel costs. A rapid and significant decline in diesel fuel
prices would reduce the Company's revenue and yield.
Saia had operating revenue of $754.0 million in 2005, an increase of
16.8 percent over 2004 operating revenue of $645.4 million. Saia's operating
revenue excluding fuel surcharge was $679.9 million in 2005, up 11.9 percent
from $607.8 million in 2004. Saia's LTL revenue per hundredweight (a measure of
yield) increased 8.0 percent to $11.10 per hundredweight for 2005 and LTL
revenue per hundredweight excluding fuel surcharge increased 3.1 percent. Saia
experienced stronger price increases in 2005 over 2004, largely due to the
continuation of a more favorable pricing environment that began in the second
half of 2004. This pricing environment allowed Saia to achieve better contract
renewal rates with customers than in the 2003 and the first half of 2004.
However, pricing remains competitive in regional markets. Saia LTL tonnage was
up 8.1 percent to 3.1 million tons and LTL shipments were up 6.6 percent to
5.6 million shipments. Management believes that Saia continues to grow volume by
providing high quality service for its customers, continued market share gains
from its 2004 Midwest expansion, recent industry consolidation in Saia's market
segments, sales initiatives in specific market segments and general economic
growth. Approximately 75 percent of Saia's revenue is subject to individual
customer price adjustment negotiations that occur intermittently throughout the
year. The remaining 25 percent of revenue is subject to an annual general rate
increase. On May 2, 2005, Saia implemented a 5.9 percent general rate increase
for customers comprising this 25 percent of revenue. Competitive factors,
customer turnover and mix changes impact the extent to which customer rate
increases are retained over time.
Jevic had operating revenue of $345.3 million in 2005, a 2.5 percent increase
over $336.9 million in 2004. Jevic's operating revenue excluding fuel surcharge
was $309.8 million in 2005, down 2.2 percent from $316.7 million in 2004.
Jevic's total revenue per hundredweight increased 5.6 percent to $7.51, while
revenue per hundredweight excluding fuel surcharge increased only 0.5 percent.
Jevic's tonnage was down 2.9 percent to 2.2 million tons and shipments were down
3.8 percent to 1.0 million shipments. Jevic's year over year tonnage decline was
most pronounced in the second and third quarters of 2005. Management believes
the decline in tonnage was in part due to a loss of business resulting from
service challenges experienced in the latter third of 2004 as well as other
competitive and customer specific effects. In the fourth quarter of 2005,
Jevic's year over year tonnage comparison improved compared to second and third
quarters, which management believes was due in part to capacity constraints in
the truckload market that increased Jevic's truckload revenue. Approximately
60 percent of Jevic's revenue is subject to individual customer price adjustment
negotiations that occur intermittently throughout the year. The remaining
40 percent of revenue is subject to an annual general rate increase. On June 6,
2005, Jevic implemented a 5.6 percent general rate increase for customers
comprising this 40 percent of revenue. Competitive factors, customer turnover
and mix changes impact the extent to which customer rate increases are retained
over time.
Operating expenses and margin
Consolidated 2005 operating income improved significantly to $54.6 million,
including a pre-tax real estate gain of $7.0 million, compared to 2004 operating
income of $40.8 million which included $2.1 million in integration charges at
Saia related to the Clark Bros. acquisition and $4.4 million in charges at Jevic
to reflect actuarially estimated increases in the workers' compensation
liability related to claims in prior years. Exclusive of these items, Saia
showed operating income improvement in excess of $10 million, reflecting higher
margin contribution on year over year volume increases and yield improvement
partially offset by structural cost increases. This operating income improvement
was offset by a significant margin decline at Jevic. Jevic's decreased margin
was largely due to the impact of revenue declines, which created diseconomies of
scale with regard to fixed costs in their operating model. The consolidated 2005
operating ratio (operating expenses divided by operating revenue) was 95.0
compared to 95.8 in 2004. However, excluding the real estate gain, the
consolidated 2005 operating ratio was 95.7. Saia continued initiatives to manage
productivity and control variable costs as monthly volumes fluctuated. The
impact of higher margin and volume increases at Saia were partially offset by
structural cost increases in wage rates, purchased transportation, healthcare
costs and other operating expenses. In August, Jevic named a new president to
lead the evaluation and implementation of a series of initiatives designed to
improve operations and profitability with a focus on growing LTL tonnage,
improving cost effectiveness and enhancing revenue quality. Higher fuel prices
(exclusive of taxes), in conjunction with volume changes, caused $39.6 million
of the increase in operating expenses and supplies. Purchased transportation
costs increased 7.6 percent as decreased utilization was more than
offset by increased costs per mile largely driven by fuel price increases and
capacity constraints, including a tight driver market and impacts of hours of
service regulations. Increased revenues from the fuel surcharge program more
than offset the effect of these fuel price increases.
Saia had operating income of $55.3 million in 2005, which included a
$7.0 million real estate gain, compared to $35.8 million in 2004 which included
a $2.1 million integration charge. Also during 2005, several hurricanes caused
property damage to some of Saia's Gulf Coast and Florida terminals and disrupted
operations, which adversely impacted their operating results. In addition to
lost revenue due to these storms, service recovery efforts at Saia resulted in
significant incremental wage and other operating and administrative expense
primarily in the third and fourth quarters. In the fourth quarter, the Company
recorded a partial insurance recovery of $1.0 million for losses attributable to
Hurricane Katrina. This amount approximates management's estimate of actual
fourth quarter effects of the hurricanes. The remaining insurance recovery,
which management expects to be in excess of this amount, will be recognized upon
reaching a negotiated settlement for the remaining claims. The operating ratio
at Saia was 92.7 in 2005 compared to 94.4 in 2004. Saia's operating ratio was
93.6 excluding the $7.0 million real estate gain in 2005 compared to 94.1 in
2004, excluding the $2.1 million integration charge. Saia improved its operating
income through yield improvement, increased volume as well as continued strong
cost controls. The higher volumes, improved yields and cost controls allowed
Saia to leverage its fixed cost network and offset higher cargo and bodily
injury and property damage claims costs, a general wage increase in August 2005
and other wage adjustments during the year. As of the fourth quarter 2005,
Saia's wage rates were approximately 2.8 percent higher than the fourth quarter
of 2004.
Jevic operating income was $3.1 million in 2005, versus $8.9 million in 2004.
Jevic's 2004 results include approximately $4.4 million charge to workers'
compensation expense related to an increase in the actuarially estimated
liability for claims from prior years. Jevic's volume decline and very modest
yield improvement hurt fixed cost coverage and contributed to variable
diseconomies that were only partially offset by salary and other general and
administrative expense reductions and other operating expense savings. However,
in 2005, Jevic's service execution was consistently high, an improvement over
2004 service performance. In August, Jevic named a new president to lead the
evaluation and implementation of a series of initiatives designed to improve
operations and profitability with a focus on growing LTL tonnage, improving cost
effectiveness and enhancing revenue quality. The operating ratio at Jevic was
99.1 in 2005, compared to 97.4 in 2004, which includes the higher workers'
compensation expense discussed above. Jevic implemented planned wage increases
in September 2005. As of the fourth quarter 2005, Jevic's wage rates were
approximately 2.7 percent higher than the fourth quarter of 2004.
Net holding company operating expenses in excess of costs allocated to the
operating companies were $3.8 million in 2005 compared to $3.9 million in 2004.
Total holding company costs were $9.5 million in 2005 compared to $9.0 million
in 2004. Holding company costs in 2005 include approximately $0.8 million in
severance costs associated with the change in management at Jevic in August 2005
and a $0.3 million increase in other operating expenses. This cost increase was
offset by a decrease in equity based compensation charges which were about
$1.0 million lower in 2005 compared to 2004.
Other
Substantially all SCST non-operating expenses represent interest expense.
Interest costs were $9.8 million in 2005 versus $9.7 million in 2004. Average
outstanding indebtedness did not change significantly between 2005 and 2004
while interest rates rose in 2005 on the smaller variable rate portion of the
Company's debt. The Company's capital structure consists predominantly of
longer-term, fixed rate instruments. The consolidated effective tax rate was
39.5 percent in 2005 compared to 38.7 percent in 2004. The 2005 effective tax
rate included approximately $0.4 million in tax benefit related to prior tax
years. The 2004 effective tax rate was lower due to a $0.6 million tax benefit
related to the favorable settlement of various tax issues. The notes to the
consolidated financial statements provide an analysis of the income tax
provision and the effective tax rate.
Working capital/capital expenditures
The decrease in working capital is predominantly the result of higher accounts
payable at December 31, 2005 due to approximately $8.9 million in trailer
purchases delivered late in 2005 and higher wage and employee benefit accruals
that more than offset an increase in accounts receivable. The increase in
accounts receivable reflects the higher revenues (both volume and yield) in
December 2005 versus December 2004. The 2005 capital investments were
$67.6 million on a gross basis and $53.7 million on a net basis. Proceeds from
the disposition of assets included $8.8 million for the disposition of a Saia
terminal in Jacksonville, Florida with excess capacity. Net capital expenditures
of $53.7 million include approximately $2.1 million investment in real estate
and $51.6 million for
replacement of revenue equipment and investment in technology equipment and
software. By subsidiary, Saia net capital expenditures were $34 million
consisting of $45 million in additions and $11 million in dispositions and Jevic
net capital expenditures were $20 million, consisting of $23 million in
additions and $3 million in dispositions.
Year ended December 31, 2004 vs. year ended December 31, 2003
Revenue and volume
Consolidated revenue increased 18.7 percent to $982.3 million as a result of
improved pricing and increased volumes as both shipments and LTL tonnage were up
over the prior year. Volume gains were attributable to improved economic
conditions, company specific initiatives and the February 16, 2004 acquisition
of Clark Bros., which was subsequently merged into Saia on May 1, 2004. On a pro
forma basis, including Clark Bros. revenue in the prior-year comparison,
consolidated revenues were up 10.8 percent. Fuel surcharge revenue, which was
5.9 percent of total revenue in 2004, was up significantly from 2003 when fuel
surcharge revenue was 3.6 percent of total revenue and is intended to reduce the
Company's exposure to rising diesel prices.
Saia had operating revenue of $645.4 million in 2004, an increase of
24.0 percent over 2003 operating revenue of $520.7 million. Saia's operating
revenue excluding fuel surcharge was $607.8 million in 2004, up 21.0 percent
from $502.3 million in 2003. On a pro forma basis, including Clark Bros. revenue
in the prior-year comparison, Saia revenue was up 11.4 percent over 2003. Saia
LTL revenue per hundredweight excluding fuel surcharge (a measure of yield)
increased 1.1 percent to $9.64 per hundredweight for 2004. Saia experienced
stronger price increases in the second half of 2004. Saia LTL tonnage was up
20.1 percent to 2.9 million tons and LTL shipments were up 17.5 percent to
5.3 million shipments. On a pro forma basis including Clark Bros. in the prior
year comparisons, LTL tonnage was up 6.7 percent and LTL shipments were up
3.0 percent. Yield improvement during the second half of 2004 is attributable to
a better pricing environment that allowed Saia to achieve better contract
renewal rates with customers than in the past two years. However, pricing
remained competitive in regional markets. Management believes that Saia
continued to grow volume by providing high quality service for its customers and
from sales initiatives in specific market segments. Approximately 75 percent of
Saia's revenue is subject to individual customer price adjustment negotiations
that occur intermittently throughout the year. The remaining 25 percent of
revenue is subject to the annual general rate increase. On June 1, 2004, Saia
implemented a 6.2 percent general rate increase for this smaller group of
customers. Competitive factors, customer turnover and mix changes impact the
extent to which customer rate increases are retained over time.
Jevic had operating revenue of $336.9 million in 2004, a 9.8 percent increase
over $306.7 million in 2003. Jevic's operating revenue excluding fuel surcharge
was $316.7 million in 2004, up 7.2 percent from $295.5 million in 2003. Jevic
total revenue per hundredweight excluding fuel surcharge increased 3.5 percent
to $6.67 per hundredweight, tonnage was up 3.0 percent to 2.3 million tons and
shipments were up 1.3 percent to 1.0 million shipments. Jevic's revenue increase
was due to increased truckload volume, improved yields and increased brokerage
revenue. The increase in yield was primarily a result of an improved pricing
environment for both LTL and truckload business. Approximately 60 percent of
Jevic's revenue is subject to individual customer price adjustment negotiations
that occur intermittently throughout the year. The remaining 40 percent of
revenue is subject to the annual general rate increase. On June 21, 2004, Jevic
implemented a 6.0 percent general rate increase on LTL business and a
5.0 percent increase on truckload business for this smaller group of customers.
Competitive factors, customer turnover and mix changes impact the extent to
which customer rate increases are retained over time.
Operating expenses and margin
The 24.2 percent increase in consolidated operating income reflects higher
margin contribution on year over year volume increases; yield improvement and
cost and productivity improvements partially offset by structural cost
increases. Operating income in 2004 also includes $2.1 million in integration
charges at Saia related to the Clark Bros. acquisition and $4.4 million in
charges at Jevic to reflect actuarially estimated increases in the workers'
compensation liability related to claims in prior years. Operating income in
2004 benefited from net operating gains of $2.5 million from the sale of revenue
equipment and gains of $0.6 million from the sale of one real estate facility.
The 2004 operating ratio (operating expenses divided by operating revenue) was
95.8 compared to 96.0 in 2003. Excluding the integration charges, workers'
compensation charges and property gains described above, the consolidated
operating ratio in 2004 was 95.5. In February 2004 Saia acquired Clark Bros., a
Midwestern less than truckload operation serving 11 states. During the first
half of the year, Saia recorded $2.1 million in charges related to the May 2004
integration of this company into Saia. During the third quarter, Saia incurred
additional costs to enhance its service primarily in new geography resulting
from the first quarter acquisition of Clark Bros. Also in the
third quarter and in the fourth quarter Jevic recorded $6.0 million in higher
than anticipated workers' compensation expense based on the results of an
actuarial valuation of their workers' compensation liability completed in the
fourth quarter 2004. Approximately $4.4 million related to increases in the
liability for claims from prior years and the remaining $1.6 million represented
an increase in estimated 2004 claims expense. Both Saia and Jevic continued
initiatives to improve productivity and control variable costs as monthly
volumes fluctuated. These costs and productivity initiatives were partially
offset by structural cost increases in wage rates, purchased transportation,
healthcare costs and other operating expenses. Higher fuel prices (exclusive of
taxes), in conjunction with volume changes, caused $25.1 million of the increase
in operating expenses and supplies. These fuel price increases were more than
offset by increased revenues from the fuel surcharge program.
Saia had operating income of $35.8 million in 2004, compared to $27.7 million in
2003. The operating ratio at Saia was 94.4 in 2004 compared to 94.7 in 2003.
Saia's operating ratio was 94.1 excluding the $2.1 million integration charge in
2004. Saia improved its operating income through yield improvement, increased
volume due in part to the Clark Bros. acquisition and continued strong cost
controls. The higher volumes, improved yields and cost controls allowed Saia to
. . .
|
|